page??? Across the UK, wildlife is clawing its way back – or at least it’s trying to.

In this podcast series, Peter Cairns explores the fault lines dividing opinion over nature’s future.

It’s a story of contradictions, competing interests, and very different visions for what the wild looks like.

Welcome to At the Edge.

  • “Listen to the science!”

    “Listen to the science!”

    An expensive German car pulled into the farmyard, moving gingerly between puddles and muck. Moments later, a shiny-shoed agricultural salesman emerged.

    “Mr Bowser!” he called, addressing my father who, after a cursory glance, had returned to his work. “Have I got a good buy for you.”

    “And I’ve got a good buy for you,” my father replied. “Goodbye.”

    Later, when I quizzed my Dad on his behaviour, he shrugged off any suggestion of rudeness.

    “We buy from those we know and trust,” he said.

    Many years have since passed, but every time I witness awkward conversations between conservationists and land managers like my Dad, my mind drifts back to that day. As they desperately try to communicate the urgency of restoring our degraded ecosystems, environmentalists are so often met with a shrug of the shoulders and a smile laden with derision.

    Climate change is intensifying, biodiversity crashing; human activity is the main driver of both – the evidence of this is quite clear. So when faced with apparent indifference, conservationists may be tempted to give in to their frustration and demand that land managers “listen to the science!” I’ve seen these conversations play out. They rarely end well.

    So, why aren’t people heeding the warnings?

    If the people they hope to engage are turning a deaf ear, conservationists must try to understand why.

    It’s important to stress that science does matter. Without raw data, we would be reduced to trading unevidenced opinions. However, science is not the only – or indeed the most compelling – tool at conservationists’ disposal. If the people they hope to engage are turning a deaf ear, they must try to understand why.

    The first question to ask is: Are they communicating in a way that encourages others to listen? Few of us are moved by facts and figures; many are demotivated by the stories of environmental loss that these statistics usually reveal. Firing them at stakeholders – be they politicians, farmers or members of the public – and expecting them to take positive action feels naïve. Indeed, it may have the opposite effect: alienating the very people they need to get on board.

    The veracity of science is often judged on who carried it out, who is presenting it and who is perceived to have paid for it.

    The success or failure of a conversation can also hinge upon choice of words. As a farmers’ child, I am instinctively wary of people talking down to me. Some things we learn without ever having to be taught. Conservationists seen to be toying with land managers, dazzling them with long words, trying to win an argument rather than genuinely engage, will quickly lose their audience.

     Just as important as what is said, and how, is the question of who is speaking. The veracity of science is often judged on who carried it out, who is presenting it and who is perceived to have paid for it.

    Meanwhile, many land managers have their own ‘science’, born from decades of lived experience. In conservationists’ haste to promote their own facts and figures, this has often been overlooked.

    Environmental communicators therefore face several challenges if they’re to rise above the fate of that mistrusted salesman. Can they find common ground with their audiences, learn to speak the same language? Are they as adept at listening as they are at talking? Can they show humility and recognise the value of lived experience? Too often, the answer to these questions has been a resounding “no.”

    Conservation’s job then, is to read the room and the people within it. Only by understanding what diverse audiences respond to, and crafting narratives that speak to their needs and values, can they hope to make themselves heard. Communication is an art, not a science.


    USEFUL LINKS

    SCOTLAND: The Big Picture Hearts and Minds Report

  • “Not another predator.”

    “Not another predator.”

    “When a song thrush eats a snail, there are no tears for the alien-looking mollusc that would otherwise ruin our garden plants. The act of predation itself involves no obvious pain; there is no heart-racing hunt or agonising death…this act of predation seems scarcely worthy of the description. However, if a sparrowhawk swoops into the garden and grasps the thrush in its dagger-like talons, we can feel hostility towards the hawk and a desire to help the songbird.”

    So wrote Mary Colwell in Beak, Tooth and Claw, a book with much to teach us about our inconsistent relationship with predators. At a time when grey seals, pine martens, goshawks and others, are rebounding from extirpation or historic lows, when growing calls for the return of lynx or the continued expansion of white-tailed eagles are met with cries of “Not another predator!” Colwell’s insights feel especially pertinent.

    Which of our many carnivores and omnivores do we look upon as predators? Which acts of killing are acceptable to us, and how does the way we speak about predatory animals impact our willingness to share space with them?

    How do we decide which predators are the ‘bullies’ and which are the ‘victims’?

    People have long taken a dim view of certain animals killing certain others. Through folklore, fairytales and latterly the popular media, we’ve sought to frame acts of predation in terms of human morality: Good vs evil. Strong vs weak. Bully vs victim.

    Note how the fox became “cunning”. Or how red kites – “gleds” as Scots historically knew them – became “greedy gleds” thanks to misplaced ideas that they decimated gamebird populations. As recently as last year, a leading farming newspaper wrote of “brazen” sea eagles killing lambs on Scotland’s west coast. The title of the article? “Angel of Death Stalks the Skies.”

    When the fox raids the pheasant pen, we reach for the gun. How often do we pause to consider how many invertebrates the millions of non-native pheasants released each year will go on to hoover up? Where is our anger for them, or for the native species that might otherwise have fed upon them?

    When pine martens take the occasional red squirrel, we call for their protections to be dropped. Seldom do we consider that martens might actually boost squirrel numbers by killing food rivals like voles and wood mice. And such is our affection for the red squirrel that when they raid birds’ nests, we turn a blind eye. Many people are reluctant to believe that this even happens.

    So, how do we decide which predators are the ‘bullies’ and which are the ‘victims’, which species are perceived to be wanton killers, and which are acknowledged to be part of the natural order? Often, it comes down to such subjective criteria as how big the animal is, how colourful, whether it has a hooked beak, sharp claws or teeth. Sometimes it’s a question of what they kill. If we deem an animal cute, empathise with it or attach a value to it (financial, emotional or otherwise), we are unlikely to root for its predator.

    Whatever our reasons, our perspectives are often contradictory. In a chain reaction, the way we think and feel about wildlife then dictates the way that we speak about it, the way we act towards it. Questions of which animals we let live and which must die, which can be reintroduced, and which remain forever banished, are often decided based on emotion rather than science or rationality.

    Yet, as great thinkers from Kant to Gandhi to Einstein have noted, a person’s humanity – and perhaps a society’s progress towards decency – can be judged by how we treat animals. This counts, not just for pets and livestock, but also our wild neighbours. And at a time when we have pushed so many of them to the brink of extinction, it counts more than ever.

    Like it or not, we will have to share our landscapes with carnivores.

    As we move beyond the quarter point of the 21st century, the UK faces certain realities. Badger, fox and marten have defied our best efforts to wipe them from this island. Sea eagles and kites will not be exterminated again but will instead grow in number. At some stage, perhaps soon, society may well decide that what the country needs is indeed “another predator” and allow lynx to come home. Like it or not, the fact of the matter is that we will have to share our landscapes with carnivores and be confronted with their predatory behaviour.

    All of which leaves us a choice. Do we take the path of misery: continue merely to co-occur with them, trapped in some loveless marriage, grudgingly sharing a space for the remainder of time? Or are we smart, empathetic and humane enough to forge new ways forward and try instead to co-exist, even co-prosper?

    If we are ever to achieve the latter, we must surely try to understand the natural world better, acknowledge that it is interlinked in ways beyond our imaginings, accept that it is red in beak, tooth and claw.

    We must understand ourselves better too. The greatest barriers to coexistence may be the ones we erect in our minds.

    Throughout history, we’ve killed certain predators in unspeakable ways, done everything possible to eradicate them from our lives, fatally unbalancing ecosystems in the process. Confused and contradictory thinking has clouded our past, but it needn’t shape our future.


    USEFUL LINKS

    CoCo Project – co-creating coexistence

    SUGGESTED READING

    Mary Colwell: Beak, Tooth & Claw

    Peter Cairns and Mark Hamblin: Tooth & Claw

  • “You Can’t Eat Trees.”

    “You Can’t Eat Trees.”

    Rising input costs. Cheap food culture. Climate change – these are just a few of the pressures facing UK farmers. Set against this backdrop, the drive to restore nature to this island is often seen as the straw that will break the camel’s back. “You can’t eat trees!” has become a rallying cry for those who fear losing their businesses or, worse, being driven from the land to make way for woodland and wildlife.

    So, will ecological restoration force farmers out of business and increase the UK’s reliance on imported food? Is rewilding really a threat to food security?

    40% of our most productive land grows crops to feed farm animals rather than people.

    To answer these questions, we must first tease apart another: what does food security actually mean? Let’s take the World Food Bank’s definition: a food-secure nation is one where ‘all people, at all times, have physical and economic access to sufficient safe and nutritious food’. By this measure, the UK, where so many people rely on food banks, already fails the test.1 Nor are we self-sufficient in terms of production: 48% of the total food we consume is imported.2

    To further complicate matters, we waste 12.8 million tonnes of food annually,3 while 40% of our most productive land grows crops to feed farm animals rather than people.4

    The implications of this skewed system are clear. At a time when people are increasingly struggling to afford food, millions of tonnes of edible produce are wasted and millions of acres of arable land are growing non-essential crops. How much more food secure might we be if the system wasn’t so profoundly broken? I’ve often put this question to those who promote the ‘rewilding threatens food security’ argument; I’ve yet to receive a coherent answer.

    Just 1% of our land is being rewilded, while 69% is farmed.

    It’s true that elements of ecological restoration – species reintroductions, for example – can affect the livelihoods of individual farmers. If we want land managers to coexist with resurgent populations of beavers, sea eagles and wild boar, the public must support them in doing so. And yes, the landholdings of the so-called ‘green lairds’ can be large. But as a proportion of the UK as a whole, they amount to very little. Just 1% of our land is being actively rewilded5. By way of comparison, 69% is farmed6.

    Could rewilding really endanger national food security? The stats suggest not. When one considers the range of threats that farmers really do face, why has rewilding come to draw so much flak?

    As a farmer, there is little that can be done about many of the variables that affect profitability. Who does one challenge about the weather, international trade deals or rural depopulation? These issues are systemic and, as such, faceless. A rewilder, however, may live in your community. Your children may attend the same school; they may have moved in from another area and hold very different worldviews from your own. It is tempting to attack those we don’t fully understand – and who, in turn, don’t appear to understand us.

    Farmers have done what was asked of them – produce food.

    My take, however, is that the fault-line runs even deeper than that. Rewilding poses existential questions for farmers, challenging perceptions of who they are, where they fit in and what their purpose in life is.

    With an average age of 59, UK farmers are the children of the post-war era of agricultural intensification. For their entire working lives, food production has been prized above all else – and for good reason. After the war, the government vowed that the people would not starve again. Farmers have done what was asked of them: produce food.

    But now the environmental crisis is upon us. The ecosystems that sustain farming, so that it can sustain all of us, are threatened as never before. If we are to turn the tide, agriculture, as the dominant land use on this island, will have to bear much of the load.

    To ask someone who has spent nearly six decades taming nature to suddenly relinquish control and allow the wild back is to demand an impressive feat of mental gymnastics. How many people willingly take up gymnastics in their late fifties?

    There are many issues to contend with. The question is: how do we find solutions?

    It begins, I think, with a conversation. People on both sides of the farming-versus-rewilding debate must step out from their camps, meet in the middle, openly share their concerns and listen to those of others. Here, then, is my attempt to open such a conversation.

    I do not believe that rewilding can credibly be called a threat to national food security, however we define that hazy term. In truth, I believe that this entire debate is a smokescreen, preventing us from seeing the very real and present dangers facing our food production system – chief among them may just be the system itself.

    No, we cannot eat trees. But nor can we expect ecologically denuded landscapes to feed us indefinitely.

    What ought we to produce, and where? How much wild nature are we prepared to live alongside? How do we support land managers to adapt to sweeping change?

    In this most heated of debates, there are valid issues to resolve. But those who question whether we can remain food secure and restore functional ecosystems have missed the point entirely.

    We cannot remain food secure without restoring them.


    REFERENCES

    1. Source: House of Commons Library ↩︎
    2. Source: Global Food Security Programme foodsecurity.ac.uk/ ↩︎
    3. Source: WWF Hidden Waste Report wwwf.org.uk ↩︎
    4. Source: wwwf.org.uk ↩︎
    5. Source: Rewilding Britain rewildingbritain.org.uk ↩︎
    6. Source: UK Government www.gov.uk ↩︎

  • “Who says we’re nature-depleted?”

    “Who says we’re nature-depleted?”


    For anyone who frequents Facebook rewilding pages, the interaction was depressingly familiar. One man repeated the well-worn statement: “The UK is one of the most nature-depleted places on Earth.” Another took issue with it. Five minutes later, one had been called a murderous psychopath, the other accused of bestiality. Nothing was achieved and neither party made the slightest dent in the other’s thinking.


    This petulant exchange might seem unworthy of further comment, but barely a day goes by without someone in conservation casually spouting the “world’s most nature-depleted country” claim. When it comes to conversations about how our land is managed, there are few statements more inflammatory.

    But what does “nature-depleted” actually mean? Why does the term elicit such a furious reaction, and what lessons might conservationists learn from this?

    Let’s deal with these questions in order.

    “Nature-depleted” is a term used to describe places that have lost much of their wildlife and habitats due to human activity. It gained prominence following the creation of the modelling metric, the Biodiversity Intactness Index (BII). The Index estimates the percentage of living organisms that remain in countries around the world. By comparing current biodiversity levels to that of similar, near-undisturbed sites, it demonstrates how ecological communities respond to human pressures.

    Anyone can see that we have lost much of what we formerly had.

    Using the BII, the latest State of Nature Report tells us that the UK is nature-depleted. There should be nothing surprising or controversial about this – anyone can see that we have lost much of what we formerly had. Gone are many of our large mammals – lynx, wolves, bears, elk and aurochs. Victorian gamekeeper records tell us how much wildlife was here until even more recently. And within our own lifetimes, most of us have noticed further declines in species and habitats. To our children, the idea that hedgehogs were once common, that a drive on a summer’s night would leave windscreens covered with dead insects, that trees once stood where housing estates are now located, would seem the stuff of fantasy.

    This island has evidently slipped far from its natural state. But then so has most of the developed world. According to the BII, the average global biodiversity intactness is 75%. This lies well below the 90% said to be a safe limit to allow vital processes like pollination to happen. What makes the UK’s situation more alarming is the estimate that we have lost significantly more than other countries. With just 53% of our original biodiversity said to remain, the Index ranks us in the bottom 10% of nations worldwide.

    Unflattering comparisons with other countries can inspire (or shame) governments into improving policy; they can galvanise certain individuals into positive action for nature. But, as we see in countless arguments across mainstream and social media, they often provoke the opposite reaction, leading people to double-down in defiance.

    There are multiple reasons for this: a sense that the figures do not accord with what people see on the ground; a distrust of scientific models, their creators and supporters. And central to all of this is the belief that conservationists are taking a simple fact – that we have lost a lot of wildlife – and using it to attack the people who manage land. If nature-depletion comparisons are met with anger, it’s because many people believe them to be unfair.

    When they hear these words, they also hear the implicit accusation: “and it’s your fault.”

    They have a point. The choices land managers make inevitably impact the environment, but many other factors have also contributed to UK nature loss. We are a small island with an increasingly erratic climate. Industrial and agricultural revolutions began here. We endured two world wars. And, in England at least, the human population and its associated levels of consumption, has grown significantly. Yet these facts are seldom referenced when arguments grow heated. Land managers are bound to dig their heels in when they are repeatedly told that we are nature-depleted. When they hear these words, they also hear the implicit accusation: “and it’s your fault.”

    Restoring what has been lost is a must. Too many missing pieces and the living systems on which we all depend will cease to function, threatening everything and everyone.

    But to turn the tide, we must ask whether nature-depletion comparisons are still helpful.

    My take? This is one lever conservationists have pulled too often. The argument is losing its potency. It’s important to understand how much nature we once had, but more important to avoid further division, because we need to come together and agree the steps necessary to create a nature-rich, climate-resilient future.


    USEFUL LINKS

    State of Nature Report: https://stateofnature.org.uk/

    SUGGESTED READING

    Roger Lovegrove: Silent Fields – The Long Decline of a Nation’s Wildlife.

    Mark Cocker: Our Place – Can we Save Britain’s Wildlife?