“Listen to the science!”

Words by Tom Bowser
Image by Mark Hamblin

An expensive German car pulled into the farmyard, moving gingerly between puddles and muck. Moments later, a shiny-shoed agricultural salesman emerged.

“Mr Bowser!” he called, addressing my father who, after a cursory glance, had returned to his work. “Have I got a good buy for you.”

“And I’ve got a good buy for you,” my father replied. “Goodbye.”

Later, when I quizzed my Dad on his behaviour, he shrugged off any suggestion of rudeness.

“We buy from those we know and trust,” he said.

Many years have since passed, but every time I witness awkward conversations between conservationists and land managers like my Dad, my mind drifts back to that day. As they desperately try to communicate the urgency of restoring our degraded ecosystems, environmentalists are so often met with a shrug of the shoulders and a smile laden with derision.

Climate change is intensifying, biodiversity crashing; human activity is the main driver of both – the evidence of this is quite clear. So when faced with apparent indifference, conservationists may be tempted to give in to their frustration and demand that land managers “listen to the science!” I’ve seen these conversations play out. They rarely end well.

So, why aren’t people heeding the warnings?

If the people they hope to engage are turning a deaf ear, conservationists must try to understand why.

It’s important to stress that science does matter. Without raw data, we would be reduced to trading unevidenced opinions. However, science is not the only – or indeed the most compelling – tool at conservationists’ disposal. If the people they hope to engage are turning a deaf ear, they must try to understand why.

The first question to ask is: Are they communicating in a way that encourages others to listen? Few of us are moved by facts and figures; many are demotivated by the stories of environmental loss that these statistics usually reveal. Firing them at stakeholders – be they politicians, farmers or members of the public – and expecting them to take positive action feels naïve. Indeed, it may have the opposite effect: alienating the very people they need to get on board.

The veracity of science is often judged on who carried it out, who is presenting it and who is perceived to have paid for it.

The success or failure of a conversation can also hinge upon choice of words. As a farmers’ child, I am instinctively wary of people talking down to me. Some things we learn without ever having to be taught. Conservationists seen to be toying with land managers, dazzling them with long words, trying to win an argument rather than genuinely engage, will quickly lose their audience.

 Just as important as what is said, and how, is the question of who is speaking. The veracity of science is often judged on who carried it out, who is presenting it and who is perceived to have paid for it.

Meanwhile, many land managers have their own ‘science’, born from decades of lived experience. In conservationists’ haste to promote their own facts and figures, this has often been overlooked.

Environmental communicators therefore face several challenges if they’re to rise above the fate of that mistrusted salesman. Can they find common ground with their audiences, learn to speak the same language? Are they as adept at listening as they are at talking? Can they show humility and recognise the value of lived experience? Too often, the answer to these questions has been a resounding “no.”

Conservation’s job then, is to read the room and the people within it. Only by understanding what diverse audiences respond to, and crafting narratives that speak to their needs and values, can they hope to make themselves heard. Communication is an art, not a science.


USEFUL LINKS

SCOTLAND: The Big Picture Hearts and Minds Report